personal finance: accounting software MS money Quickbooks Quicken SaaS Sage
- May 2013 (4)
- April 2013 (4)
- March 2013 (4)
- February 2013 (6)
- January 2013 (5)
- December 2012 (3)
- November 2012 (3)
- October 2012 (8)
- September 2012 (10)
- August 2012 (5)
- July 2012 (7)
- June 2012 (5)
- May 2012 (12)
- April 2012 (5)
- March 2012 (5)
- February 2012 (5)
- January 2012 (7)
- December 2011 (6)
- November 2011 (8)
- October 2011 (6)
- September 2011 (3)
- August 2011 (8)
- July 2011 (5)
- June 2011 (8)
- May 2011 (7)
- April 2011 (9)
- March 2011 (9)
- February 2011 (3)
- January 2011 (8)
- December 2010 (10)
- November 2010 (7)
- October 2010 (10)
- September 2010 (8)
- August 2010 (6)
- July 2010 (10)
- June 2010 (13)
- May 2010 (10)
- April 2010 (16)
- November 2007 (1)
I don’t know how other people manage their personal finances, but this problem was solved for me around the dotcom crash on buying Quicken. Most people seem to think of their personal finances in terms of a single number, the amount of money they have at any time, usually the end of the month This seems to be the principles behind consumer budgeting tools like this, often advocated on the debt boards of moneysaving expert. This gives a snapshot in time, like a single frame from a movie. It’s bizarre to me that this is useful at all – either my personal finances are furiously complicated, or other people’s are one-dimensional.
I found it a lot better to look back on the expenses and income as a function of time, and Quicken lets me look back over the year. Just like a share price graph, if the trend is up its my friend, if it’s going down there should either be a reason for it or some action needs to be taken.
I also used it for my multimedia company, and there it helped with cashflow – by entering future costs, estimated future costs and estimated future revenues it told me how I would be getting on in future. Like any budgeting tool it is only as good as you are honest with your predictions.
Unfortunately Intuit quit the UK market a few years ago, and the obvious competition, Microsoft Money, also scarpered. However, Quicken remains serviceable for the moment.
Looking for a decent small-biz accounting program
It so happens that I’m looking for a program to do this job for a small company/future enterprise. I am not trained in book-keeping, but I used Quicken happily to manage my previous accounts and VAT returns, and it did the job and my company accountant seemed happy enough with the results to be able to draft the statutory accounts and HMRC jazz.
It doesn’t feel good to be using a 10-year old software package to do this job, since future versions of Windows may no longer run older code. I’ve got away with it so far. So I looked at the field, accounting software tends to be country specific because taxation varies greatly between countries. In the UK there seems to be Sage 50 which is £700 and up, QuickBooks which is £100 and upwards or a monthly rental/online of £10 which is even more expensive and doesn’t do VAT which is probably an issue, and a motley crew of wannabees and also-rans bringing up the rear around the £100-200 mark.
From my experience with Quicken I’d tend to favour QuickBooks, but the feedback on AccountingWeb seems to be that Intuit’s support makes people snarl and grizzle so maybe not. OTOH the Ermine is of the opinion that by the time things are so hosed that it ever seems a good idea to ring the manufacturer about a software problem the fight is lost. Software is sold like a used car – as seen and without any warranty express or implied.
Then we have the new kids on the block – cloud accounting software, with KashFlow, Xero, and FreeAgent. All these rough out at about £20 a month. Now I know they say that there’s no point in trying to sell anything new to anyone who’s over 40, but really, all your financial information processed and stored online? What on earth could go wrong
At least I can still use Quicken even though it’s been abandoned by the supplier in the UK. To still be using a cloud SaaS after a similar amount of time I’d have been paying ten years’ worth of usage fees (£2400!), and of course I would be relying on the company to still be actively supporting the application. No, thank you very much.
Quicken tried software rental with QuickenXG for home users in 2003. The UK market correctly interpeted this as price gouging, and rejected the product, so Quicken retired from the UK market in a huff.
What do I want accounting software to do for me?
Accounting software does two things. One is making sure that all the figures add up. In a company of more than one person, there is room for both human error and fraud, and it’s the job of the software to minimise the former and make the latter harder to do and more traceable if it happens. Most of the statutory requirements are all about making sure the figures add up and are stated accurately, as the tagline for Companies House says, ‘for the record’
Most small business owners need accounting software so they can afford to pay their accountants. You need an accountant for statutory compliance if you are a limited company, though not as a sole trader I believe. Hit him with the shoebox full of receipts and you’ll pay for his expensive time to enter it all and reconcile, give him a data file and the bank statements and receipts and it makes the whole process work easier and cheaper.
That’s not what I want it for. I want it to set strategic direction, and to be able to see the cashflow enemy up ahead. It’s the finance director’s flight instrumentation panel, and it puzzles me why SMEs often outsource this book-keeping function. You shouldn’t be in business if you can’t achieve about a 5% return on capital employed (ROCE) or more in the long run. Just like Quicken in my personal finances, with my previous company it allowed me to see how much cost is going into something. No ifs or buts. I’ve seen entrepreneurs flog themselves in business not really making much money at all. They’ve lost sight of their ROCE, or got so emotionally hung up on the business that they haven’t observed the slow changes that rust away at the fundamentals of a once-sound business case from years ago.
An ex-bank manager related the cautionary tale of a one-man truck driver. He expanded, taking on more staff and trucks. In the end this guy was run ragged staying on top of all this, but he as basically only making the same amount of money as when he was a one-man band.
Running a working business needs continual calls on ‘is this worth doing or not?’ Not everything gives a tangible ROCE but you ought to know why you are doing something, particularly if it isn’t making money. Of course one of the things that makes running a business hard are that there are all sorts of transactional costs, that raise the cost of changing direction. It is sometimes rational to carry on a line of business even if it isn’t profitable, if the cost of shutting it down and restarting it are high (sacking and rehiring staff, etc), but it’s a hard call to make, as it is hedged all around by known unknowns and risks.
The trouble is most accounting software seems designed to do the compliance thing once a year. The cloud services do a slightly better job that I can see of allowing you to report and graph costs and revenues by item, but all of them look like a damned expensive way of doing the sort of thing that Quicken does for my personal finances. For instance if I want to know what I spend on my car then Quicken give me this
Tells me pretty much everything I need to know, including that the spikes showing the parasitic costs of owning a car (tax, insurance, servicing) cost me more than the fuel. Quicken will also spit out a report itemising these lines if necessary. What’s not to like? Why can’t accounting software just do that for me, as Quicken did for my multimedia company 10 years ago?
Is there something I am missing about book-keeping/accountancy?
After you’ve been working in companies for thirty years, you get to pick up some of the general principles they used for financial management. I’ve been lucky enough to work in a small company of about ten strong, as well as in bigger organisations. You see more of the guts in a small company, though I was a cocky upstart at the time. Nevertheless, I’ve never learned anything formally about accounting. I’d assumed that a decent knowledge of the Micawber principle, and something that would give me a time display of costs and revenues would be enough.
So I got myself onto AAT skillcheck and had a bash to establish what my level of knowledge was. I flunked double-entry bookkeeping and sucked at financial transactions:
so it’s possible that there’s something I don’t understand about what accounting software is trying to do that is giving me a hard time here. I managed to up my IT skills score to green on the second go, but the right hand two remained resolutely amber and red, so there’s obviously something about this accounting malarkey that’s outside my ken. Maybe that’s why I can’t find accounting software that tells me what I want to know, because I can’t speak the lingo.
Taking an AAT course isn’t the answer, however, due to the stupendous price of even distance learning. It is interesting to observe that Level2 is in fact the entry level (there are no level 1 courses I could see). So I am at O level rank neophyte level with bookkeeping.
Somewhere something isn’t right here. There seems to be a massive focus on making the numbers add up and compliance, whereas I want a speed and heading indicator. I’ve never had trouble making the numbers add up with Quicken. It’s also hard to believe that after running my own company and working in others for three decades that I could have blissfully sailed past something fundamentally essential in small business finance, but that’s the feedback I’m getting.
So maybe I should wing it with Quicken or GnuCash, which can deliver the strategic direction part for me, and outsource the accounting as before. My accountant 6 years ago was about £150 ex VAT ech year, probably up to £250 these days. He headed me off doing things with would have been dippy from a tax viewpoint and when you look at the price of accounting software, which seems to be regularly updated at a cost then the benefits of learning how to do this job myself start to look marginal. I clearly know jack all about double-entry bookkeeping.
From this review of GnuCash that might help me learn, at least. It appears that some of the features of Quicken actied like stabiliser wheels on a kid’s bike. I didn’t come unstuck, but I never learned how to do it right, either.
The Cast of Characters – List of UK Personal Finance and Accounting programs
Since I had to suffer the pain of doing this research it might do somebody else some good Here’s a list of the obvious contenders, marshalled into rough categories. There is a vendor lock-in and data longevity strategic issue with using proprietary solutions with proprietary formats, so Open Source versions are marked with a *
Small Business Accounting – desktop/installed standalone software
- Sage seems to be the 900 pound gorilla in this space. Lots of people really hate Sage, though I guess lots of people really hate Microsoft, so it’s one of those scale things…
- QuickBooks – sort of 600-pound gorilla…
those two are the big ones in the UK by the looks of it. All the rest bring up the rear
- TAS Books (taken over by Sage, there appears to be a free option)
- VT Transaction + / Final Accounts
- *Ledger – quite spartan, though as a result of the bare bones approach the manual is very instructive on the principles (see comments for user experience)
Web-Based – Cloud (All Your Data Are Belong to Us)
If you’re going to build your business on this you better hope that cloud biz accounting software providers are more stable that personal finance coud providers in the UK, see rant below. If a finance director of my firm advocated this solution and the provider went down I’d fire them for culpable incompetence.
Managing money is deeply embedded into any company structure, and part of why I am mulling this over so much is once you’ve set direction, changing it over is not going to be any fun at all. You can replace the foundations of a structure without dismantling it, but it ain’t easy to do compared to getting it right from the off!
- QuickBooks (online version)
- LessAccounting (US based) see comments for user experience
- FreshBooks (Canada based, UK aware)
Personal Finance Management
- MS Money – deceased. This is living proof why you should never trust commercial software for strategic long-term requirements.
- Quicken UK – deceased. More living proof why you should never trust commercial software for strategic long-term requirements, though note at least Quicken remains serviceable in 2012
- Moneydance (see comments for user experience)
Web-Based – Cloud (All Your Data Are Belong To Us)
I don’t understand how anybody would even entertain this. Maybe it’s just a generational thing, but you put an awful lot of effort into the data entry of things like this. The software vendor owns your balls. Wanna see your data – you pay them what it takes. This is a classic setup for vendor lock-in.
Clearly many other people are a lot more relaxed than I am about this. So good luck to y’all, but don’t blame me if you get price ramped later on! Something that should scare you is to read MS Money is Dead – Five Alternative Programs to keep Track of your Cash from CNet UK from June 2009 (only three years ago), and then observe that the first online service, Wesabe, has gone to a dis, the second online service, Yodlee, looks as American as apple pie and may not handle UK punters any more, the third online recommendation, Expensr, is no more and is now MoneyStrands. So that’s a 100% fail or metamorphosis into something else in three years. Do you feel lucky, punk?
I didn’t find anybody else that would deal with Brits, if you’re American than the obvious choice seems to be Mint, which is owned by Intuit, makers of Quicken and QuickBooks.
If I get to hear about other programs SaaS providers I’ll edit this.